In The Name Of God The Most Merciful, Most Compassionate

Arabism vs. Universal Islam

by Yahya Ederer
Source: onislam.net

Filed under: Featured,Islam,Islam Today |

 

There is a big misunderstanding amongst much of our immigrant community here in the West.

Sadly, the arabization of Islam has been passed on to other Muslims and non-Muslims in the west, thus making it a reality. This  article attempts to clear up this misunderstanding.

I was speaking with a sister who thought that what I am preaching in the mosque is against Arabic—which she believes is the language of Islam.

She was talking about the fact that our mosque used to do the first half of the sermon in Arabic and then a translation in English. I told them that we should follow the majority opinion of scholars in that we do a small intro in Arabic to fulfill the pillars of the sermon for those that believe sermons must be in Arabic and then only recite the scriptural references in Arabic with immediate translation. Other than that, the general preaching should be in the language of the land we live in so that the people may benefit.

Another brother who has been living in America for 20 years and is fluent in English defended the way of preaching in Arabic by saying that he prefers it that way because true preaching can only be in Arabic, and the sermon in English just doesn’t move him the same way! I told him that his feeling is reflective of ethnocentrism which is comfortable for him as opposed to others. The reality is that here in America there are many cultures of Muslims in the mosques and the unifying language among them is English. This applies especially in the long run when future generations become the majority of American Muslims.

The community claimed that even if they don’t understand Arabic, having the sermon in Arabic will encourage them to learn the language! This idealist claim is completely unrealistic for the vast majority of Muslims. The purpose of the sermon is to disseminate spiritual guidance to the congregation.

The one thing which strikes me as strange about both the juristic opinion as well as the cultural view against using English is that they are based on the idea that the Arabic language—outside of scripture—is somehow holier or superior than any other language. The fact is that when an Arab Imam makes his sermon up—outside of scriptural or other quotes—it is fully his own making. What is being said is that the ideas in the Arabic sermon which came from his mind are somehow holier or more Islamic than the ideas of an Imam who delivers it in English or any other language.

I lived in the Arab world for 5 years and I can easily confirm that I’ve heard many boring sermons with no substance in Arabic. These sermons could not begin to hold a candle to a sermon by say Imam Suhaib Webb, Zaid Shakir, Siraj Wahaj, Nouman Ali Khan etc.  Most of the time I sought out prominent Imams and I benefitted greatly, as I would from any of our skilled orators here. The reason I benefitted was not the language; rather it was the substance, style, and meaning of the speech itself.

Islam is a Universal Message

Much to our surprise, the majority of our scholars understood this point in that according to a Hadith (record of the words of Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him) they permitted the Arab to supplicate in his language freely from his own heart (which often comes out in a far from Qur’anic colloquial dialect). So the majority position of our scholars is that the supplication of a non-Arab in his or her own language is also perfectly acceptable. The logic being that this supplication is not a revelation; rather it is of their own making. I myself am a certified master of the Arabic language and I am deeply intrigued by its beauty and ability to articulate eloquent meaning in such brevity. That being said, God has revealed scripture in many languages and they were all equally divine in nature.

Many brothers from the subcontinent have told me that they were taught by their family and even their Imams to respect Arab people simply because they know/speak the language of the Quran and Sunnah(tradition of the Prophet). One response to this claim is that their knowledge of the Quran, (albeit vastly more than non-Arabs) is not nearly as good as the knowledge of the common companion of the Prophet. Secondly, the language they speak is even farther from Qur’anic Arabic. So the justification has some issues from the get-go.

Recently, I was visiting one of my original mentors and he started talking to my 5-year-old son in Arabic. The brother was upset that my son doesn’t speak conversational Arabic. I told him that if he asked him about theological concepts and phrases, by the grace of God, he will find him more advanced than the average 5-year-old Muslim regardless of their cultural background.  He then responded in dismay and commanded me to teach him to be fluent in Arabic! I said—with all due respect sheikh—my son is an American and will live here for the rest of his life. If my son expresses a desire to become a scholar of Islamic sciences then at that time I will begin a comprehensive training, starting with the Arabic language, as that is the key to such a field of expertise. Other than that, we are raising him to be a devout Muslim of the highest level of piety and God-consciousness.

Islam is a universal message that can be completely understood and practiced in any language. We teach him about Arabic concepts as we study and recite the Quran to give him reference, but other than that we don’t see fluency in Arabic as a priority. He paused for a minute and then said that the Arabic language comes with a depth of Islamic culture imbedded in it. I then reminded him that Arabs are just like any other people. They have atheists, Christians, Jews, etc. They have murderers, thieves, fornicators, liars, etc. This is throughout their history, and their fluency in Arabic did not save them from that. For those who have read the work of many great poets during the Ummayad and Abbaside Caliphates, they can see that many wrote of their love for intoxication and pedophilia.

Finding the Right Balance

The Quran tells mankind how to be the best believer:

{O mankind, indeed We have created you from male and female and made you people and tribes that you may know one another. Indeed, the most noble among you in the sight of Allah is the most righteous of you. Indeed, Allah is Knowing and Acquainted. } (Al-Hujurat 49: 13)

God is talking to all of mankind and mentioning that they are all of many different languages and cultures. He then made the criterion that it is the most pious who are the best among them. The Prophet was very aware of ethnocentrism and that Islam will be a universal message that will reach the corners of the Earth. For this reason, in his farewell pilgrimage months before he passed, he made it very clear, preaching to thousands of believers: “There is no precedence of an Arab over a non-Arab […]”

On more than one occasion, I have experienced this ethnocentrism from Arabs blatantly or indirectly accusing non-Arab Muslims of somehow being beneath them or having a lesser understanding of Islam than them. The fact is that I have met many non-Arabic speaking Muslims whose understanding and practice of Islam are higher than many practicing Arab Muslims I know.

Even when it comes to the Quran we often misrepresent the reality. I myself used to repeat the claim that much of the meaning of the Quran is lost in translation, thus negating a comprehensive understanding of Islam to non-Arabs. The truth is that the only literal word of God is the Arabic Quran which has been divinely preserved for our nation as a pure resource for true guidance in our lives.

I would say—with all due respect—that if you are using any of the older English translations of the Quran it will not necessarily lose meaning, but because of the way it was translated it doesn’t get across the meanings very well and thus seemingly looses Qur’anic meaning.

Let’s remember that English translations are barely a century old. It is undoubtedly a developing science. When reading M.A.S. Abdel-Haleem’s or better yet Yahiya Emerick’s translations, for example, you will get a much more comprehensive grasp of all of the meanings found in the Quran. You might have a long explanation for some words and phrases and it might not sound as poetic, but language is language and meanings are universal. That doesn’t make the translations an exact English replica of the infallible Quran though. Rather, they are the best human works at translating the meanings of the Quran to English and are subject to human flaw just as is an Arab’s understanding or interpretation of the Arabic itself.

In conclusion we need to balance the Arabization of Islam in that we maintain a comprehensive understanding and expression of Islam as it relates to our culture and language here in the states. At the same time, we realize that the scholarly understanding of Islam can only be attained through mastering Arabic and learning from scholars who represent the 14-century-old tradition of Islamic scholarship.

Arabic is not the language of Islam, rather it is the final language in which Islam was revealed and preserved. If we were to say that Arabic is the language of Islam then we would be saying the Prophets like Noah, Abraham, Moses and Jesus were not true Muslims since they didn’t speak or know Arabic! No Muslim is better or more authentic than another except by piety and God-consciousness.

3 comments
ASLAM
ASLAM

Arabic is a supreme language chosen by ALLAH.

bani aadam
bani aadam

On a pragmatic level, I agree a great deal with this author. Another way to test this argument is to ask ourselves if Arabic will be a factor in our entry to heaven - the answer is no. In other words, you can go on with your whole life not knowing arabic and still attain paradise.

However, I wouldnt reject learning Arabic altogether. The author, Yaya Ederer, should teach his son Arabic and not wait till he may decide to become a scholar. The reason being, although it is not the language of Islam, Arabic is the language of the Quran. I mean, there must be a reason why Allah chose the language of Arabic to deliver His final message. Maybe it is the fact that when you do hear it, it moves you, no matter if you understand it of not.

I say this because I have heard of (non Arab) people starting their conversion to Islam by hearing the Quran or Athan in Arabic - I think I can use Yvonne Ridley, a British journalist captured by the Taliban in 2001, as an example. One Scholar said to me people are moved by the Quran and other Arabic related scripture, because even if the person does not understand it, their soul does. That is, the Quran speaks to you, if you let it. So there is obviously an effect in the Arabic that you dont get in other languages.

For the general Muslim population, maybe it is also because there is a historical and emotional connection you get when you learn and understand classical Arabic. Your just one step closer to being a Sahabi like figure (our ultimate aim) and in Arabia, were it all happened!

In the end, yes, the Arabic ethnocentrism of Islam is clearly and evidently wrong. But Arabic as a language and Arabic being a tool to Arabise Muslims or a tool to create superiority over other languages, I think, are two different things. Arabic is not a necessity, but why not learn it if one can. Allah may even reward these efforts!

FearNoneButOne
FearNoneButOne

What a horrible article. Can't believe MV gave this article any credibility.

MuslimVillage Incorporated

Your continued support of MuslimVillage Inc assists in establishing and maintaining the following community initiatives:

Contact

www.muslimvillage.com
MuslimVillage Incorporated
PO Box 304
Hurstville, NSW BC 1481 Australia

Copyight © 2001–2012 MuslimVillage Incorporated